It's the end of March, about to start a new calendar quarter, and a good time to review data for the quarter just ending.
Here's an interesting figure: our 1kW PV array has produced exactly half as much energy this quarter as our home has consumed. On average, the array produced 4.20kWh per day since the start of January while we consumed 8.40kWh per day. Just a coincidence - but a nice neat 50% figure nonetheless. Got me musing about the possibility of doubling the capacity and going off-grid.
On average, we exported 1.84kWh per day to the grid, which is just under half of the energy produced by the panels. Doing the sums, we must have imported just over 6kWh a day from the grid to meet our household demands.
The new fridge has been pretty steady at just under 1.5kWh per day, or 18% of our total needs. And the energy-guzzling computer my employer provided has been kept in check with an average daily consumption of 0.38kWh, or around 4% of our total. It has taken some very aggressive energy saving measures to achieve that, but I'm reasonably happy with that result.
Just one more factoid to close out the post. This week our PV array crossed the 1MWh line for total energy produced.
Showing posts with label solar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label solar. Show all posts
Sunday, 29 March 2009
Friday, 12 December 2008
Cool! Stats
Past 11 days... average consumption 6.55 kWh/day, of which 1.36 was used by the new fridge. 32% of our consumption was supplied directly from our solar panels (just over 2 kWh/day) while another 2.64kWh was exported to the grid each day.
As a result of the low consumption and strong sunlight, we are now in negative territory for energy costs over the past 102 days (not counting the fixed service fees). The credit for our exported energy will exceed the charge for imported energy by about $2.
We've also had heaps of rain, so the tanks have been full almost constantly for the past six weeks or so.
As a result of the low consumption and strong sunlight, we are now in negative territory for energy costs over the past 102 days (not counting the fixed service fees). The credit for our exported energy will exceed the charge for imported energy by about $2.
We've also had heaps of rain, so the tanks have been full almost constantly for the past six weeks or so.
Saturday, 18 October 2008
Stats Update
In the past 45 days...
Our solar panels have produced 187kWh of electricity (4.16/day).
87kWh of that has been exported to the grid (1.93/day), while 100kWh has been used immediately in our home (2.22/day).
We have consumed an additional 279kWh from the grid (6.2/day).
Total consumption is therefore 279+100=379kWh (8.42/day).
We have also used the electric booster for our hot water occasionally: 10.9kWh total (0.24/day).
Scaled up to 3 months, our bill (should AGL ever get around to sending us one) would look like this...
Tariff 11: 558kWh @ 16.29c = $90.90
Tariff 33: 22kWh @ 9.78c = $2.16
Solar export tariff: 174kWh @ 44c = $76.56 credit
Total: $16.50
Well, except that there's a monthly service fee of $6.26 for tariff 11 and the minimum monthly cost on tariff 33 is $4.36. So that brings it up to $37.48. I'd actually save $9.50 per bill if I switched my hot water booster to tariff 11... but there's a $50 charge for the swapover, which means a 15 month payback time.
Bottom line: at this point in time our 1kW array is producing just under half of our home's total energy needs, though only about half of that is produced when we actually need it. Thanks to the government's feed-in tariff, that misalignment of supply and demand has a very positive impact on our electricity bills. The energy we export is valued at 80% of the energy we import. The additional amount we produce and consume locally is effectively worth another $33 or so that doesn't appear on the bill.
Our solar panels have produced 187kWh of electricity (4.16/day).
87kWh of that has been exported to the grid (1.93/day), while 100kWh has been used immediately in our home (2.22/day).
We have consumed an additional 279kWh from the grid (6.2/day).
Total consumption is therefore 279+100=379kWh (8.42/day).
We have also used the electric booster for our hot water occasionally: 10.9kWh total (0.24/day).
Scaled up to 3 months, our bill (should AGL ever get around to sending us one) would look like this...
Tariff 11: 558kWh @ 16.29c = $90.90
Tariff 33: 22kWh @ 9.78c = $2.16
Solar export tariff: 174kWh @ 44c = $76.56 credit
Total: $16.50
Well, except that there's a monthly service fee of $6.26 for tariff 11 and the minimum monthly cost on tariff 33 is $4.36. So that brings it up to $37.48. I'd actually save $9.50 per bill if I switched my hot water booster to tariff 11... but there's a $50 charge for the swapover, which means a 15 month payback time.
Bottom line: at this point in time our 1kW array is producing just under half of our home's total energy needs, though only about half of that is produced when we actually need it. Thanks to the government's feed-in tariff, that misalignment of supply and demand has a very positive impact on our electricity bills. The energy we export is valued at 80% of the energy we import. The additional amount we produce and consume locally is effectively worth another $33 or so that doesn't appear on the bill.
Wednesday, 30 July 2008
The meter goes backwards
It's been a long time coming but we finally have a 1KW photovoltaic array on our roof. Too much detail to post via iPhone keyboard... but I watched our meter turning the other way this arvo. Way cool.
Thursday, 29 May 2008
More water, but it's all cold
Good news: it's raining again and the tanks are now over 50% full with more falls forecast for this weekend.
Bad news: combined with the lower temperatures and reduced sun intensity of winter, the persistent cloud has forced us to switch on the electric backup for our solar hot water system. It's been seven months since the electricity company saw that meter move.
Ah well.
Bad news: combined with the lower temperatures and reduced sun intensity of winter, the persistent cloud has forced us to switch on the electric backup for our solar hot water system. It's been seven months since the electricity company saw that meter move.
Ah well.
Wednesday, 21 May 2008
A proposal for a means-tested PVRP
Following up on the previous post, this one explores some options for the design of a solar photovoltaic rebate program. Hopefully a better one than what we have in the real world today.
First let's look at the goals of the program. Overall, the intention is to invest a fixed amount of money over a fixed time period into the PV industry. There are a number of anticipated benefits for society as a whole:
- Develop the skills and infrastructure required for a sustainable PV industry
- Encourage R&D for technology improvement
- Put downward pressure on costs
- Improve competitiveness and effectiveness of PV in the long term
I would also like to throw my own goal in there (to nobody's surprise), encouraging overall reduced energy consumption in participating homes.
Now, the only reason I'm writing this is because I'm critical of the previous attempts on both sides of politics to implement this scheme. Specifically:
- A fixed rebate value skews investment heavily towards the smallest eligible system
- A fixed rebate value without a means test is socially inequitable
- An all-or-nothing means test is more equitable on average but introduces ridiculous boundary cases
- With or without the means test, the scheme ignores the number of residents in the household
The number of residents in the household is important for several reasons. In a scheme where a means test is imposed, surely the case of a single person living alone earning a hundred grand should be considered differently to a working couple with children making do on the same amount. Also, one of the factors involved in choosing whether to purchase a PV system is the amount of time it'll take to recoup the costs, and that gets us back to the topic of feed-in-tariffs. Under the import/export models being adopted by the states it's clearly easier for the single person to generate excess energy than it is for the family.
So I propose that a good rebate scheme would be variable. Different amounts should be paid in different circumstances, according to some reasonable criteria. The scheme should offer greater assistance to those with the greater need, but in all cases part of the cost must be borne by the recipients. Good in principle... but tricky to deliver. Here we go.
First I would suggest that the number of household residents be taken into account when evaluating "means". The simplest way is to divide the household income by the number of residents to work out an income-per-person figure. The single guy mentioned earlier scores $100K, the family of four comes in at $25K each. We'll come back to that in a bit.
My next proposal is that the maximum value of the rebate per household should also be relative to the number of persons. That is, a household with more people should be eligible for more rebate. However there's a risk here that providing funds too freely will encourage profit-taking in the installation industry, and this needs to be addressed.
One way to do this is to also tie the maximum applicable rebate to the generating capacity of the system being installed. We start by nominating a minimum "per-person generating capacity" figure - I'll choose 500W for convenience. Then in order to receive the full rebate for each of the four members of the family household, a system with at least 2000W rated output must be installed. If the family decided to install only a 1000W system, they would be eligible for only half as much rebate. (I hope that makes sense - I'll do some examples at the end.)
Now we need to work out the maximum rebate each person would be eligible to receive. The simplest way to do this is on a linear scale: we need to define the maximum value of the rebate and the upper limit of per-person income at which point the rebate reduces to zero. In keeping with the existing scheme, let's set the maximum rebate to $8,000 and the cut-off at $100K. That means somebody with a "means" of $50K would be eligible for $4,000; somebody worth $75K could get $2,000; and somebody enjoying a hundred grand to themself would get nothing.
Just one more thing. We really don't want to get into the situation where the value of the rebates produces upward pressure on the costs of the PV systems. So let's set an overall threshold which ensures that the household has an incentive to shop around: the total rebate payable shall not exceed 80% of the installed cost of the system.
Simple, huh? No really, it's not that complicated. Here are a couple of examples.
1. Bruce and Sharon live in a house they've bought together. Bruce is a public servant earning $50K while Shazza's cornered the market for organic lima beans and is raking in $100K. Two people in the household, with an average "means" of $75K. The household is therefore eligible for a maximum rebate of $2,000 per person, depending on the size of the array they install. With two people there's really only one option in array size: an entry-level system with a rated output of 1kW makes them eligible for the full $4,000. The best price they can find on such a system is $10,461. Since their maximum rebate is well under 80% of the total price it is paid in full and their net cost is $6,461.
2. Helen, Gary and their four kids somehow manage to get by on the $60K which Gary earns through his small business. With an average "means" of $10K per person, they are each eligible for up to $7,200 in solar rebates - provided sufficient capacity is installed. The maximum rebate would be applicable for a system rated at least 3kW (6 x 500W). Such a system is available for $26,361 - clearly far lower than the hypothetical value of the rebate at $43,200. In this case the 80% rule applies, limiting the rebate to $21,088. Helen and Gary decide they can't afford to spend over $5K even for such a large system, and instead opt for a 1.5kW system that with an 80% rebate leaves them with an outlay of just under $3K.
Some key points to remember. First, I'm just some guy with a few ideas and an internet connection. Don't crucify me if there's something really flawed with my suggestions. Second, there are a number of parameters here which could be adjusted to alter the amount of rebate payable in different circumstances, including the maximum per-person rebate amount, the threshold at which the rebate cuts out completely, the amount of generating capacity required per-person to qualify for that portion of the aggregate rebate and the fractional ceiling limiting the overall rebate as a proportion of the system's cost.
One big weakness I see here is that it's hard to predict how quickly the scheme would burn through its budget allocation. A possible remedy would be to vary the rebate parameters on a periodic basis - probably as part of each year's federal budget.
So there you go. That's enough of that I think.
First let's look at the goals of the program. Overall, the intention is to invest a fixed amount of money over a fixed time period into the PV industry. There are a number of anticipated benefits for society as a whole:
- Develop the skills and infrastructure required for a sustainable PV industry
- Encourage R&D for technology improvement
- Put downward pressure on costs
- Improve competitiveness and effectiveness of PV in the long term
I would also like to throw my own goal in there (to nobody's surprise), encouraging overall reduced energy consumption in participating homes.
Now, the only reason I'm writing this is because I'm critical of the previous attempts on both sides of politics to implement this scheme. Specifically:
- A fixed rebate value skews investment heavily towards the smallest eligible system
- A fixed rebate value without a means test is socially inequitable
- An all-or-nothing means test is more equitable on average but introduces ridiculous boundary cases
- With or without the means test, the scheme ignores the number of residents in the household
The number of residents in the household is important for several reasons. In a scheme where a means test is imposed, surely the case of a single person living alone earning a hundred grand should be considered differently to a working couple with children making do on the same amount. Also, one of the factors involved in choosing whether to purchase a PV system is the amount of time it'll take to recoup the costs, and that gets us back to the topic of feed-in-tariffs. Under the import/export models being adopted by the states it's clearly easier for the single person to generate excess energy than it is for the family.
So I propose that a good rebate scheme would be variable. Different amounts should be paid in different circumstances, according to some reasonable criteria. The scheme should offer greater assistance to those with the greater need, but in all cases part of the cost must be borne by the recipients. Good in principle... but tricky to deliver. Here we go.
First I would suggest that the number of household residents be taken into account when evaluating "means". The simplest way is to divide the household income by the number of residents to work out an income-per-person figure. The single guy mentioned earlier scores $100K, the family of four comes in at $25K each. We'll come back to that in a bit.
My next proposal is that the maximum value of the rebate per household should also be relative to the number of persons. That is, a household with more people should be eligible for more rebate. However there's a risk here that providing funds too freely will encourage profit-taking in the installation industry, and this needs to be addressed.
One way to do this is to also tie the maximum applicable rebate to the generating capacity of the system being installed. We start by nominating a minimum "per-person generating capacity" figure - I'll choose 500W for convenience. Then in order to receive the full rebate for each of the four members of the family household, a system with at least 2000W rated output must be installed. If the family decided to install only a 1000W system, they would be eligible for only half as much rebate. (I hope that makes sense - I'll do some examples at the end.)
Now we need to work out the maximum rebate each person would be eligible to receive. The simplest way to do this is on a linear scale: we need to define the maximum value of the rebate and the upper limit of per-person income at which point the rebate reduces to zero. In keeping with the existing scheme, let's set the maximum rebate to $8,000 and the cut-off at $100K. That means somebody with a "means" of $50K would be eligible for $4,000; somebody worth $75K could get $2,000; and somebody enjoying a hundred grand to themself would get nothing.
Just one more thing. We really don't want to get into the situation where the value of the rebates produces upward pressure on the costs of the PV systems. So let's set an overall threshold which ensures that the household has an incentive to shop around: the total rebate payable shall not exceed 80% of the installed cost of the system.
Simple, huh? No really, it's not that complicated. Here are a couple of examples.
1. Bruce and Sharon live in a house they've bought together. Bruce is a public servant earning $50K while Shazza's cornered the market for organic lima beans and is raking in $100K. Two people in the household, with an average "means" of $75K. The household is therefore eligible for a maximum rebate of $2,000 per person, depending on the size of the array they install. With two people there's really only one option in array size: an entry-level system with a rated output of 1kW makes them eligible for the full $4,000. The best price they can find on such a system is $10,461. Since their maximum rebate is well under 80% of the total price it is paid in full and their net cost is $6,461.
2. Helen, Gary and their four kids somehow manage to get by on the $60K which Gary earns through his small business. With an average "means" of $10K per person, they are each eligible for up to $7,200 in solar rebates - provided sufficient capacity is installed. The maximum rebate would be applicable for a system rated at least 3kW (6 x 500W). Such a system is available for $26,361 - clearly far lower than the hypothetical value of the rebate at $43,200. In this case the 80% rule applies, limiting the rebate to $21,088. Helen and Gary decide they can't afford to spend over $5K even for such a large system, and instead opt for a 1.5kW system that with an 80% rebate leaves them with an outlay of just under $3K.
Some key points to remember. First, I'm just some guy with a few ideas and an internet connection. Don't crucify me if there's something really flawed with my suggestions. Second, there are a number of parameters here which could be adjusted to alter the amount of rebate payable in different circumstances, including the maximum per-person rebate amount, the threshold at which the rebate cuts out completely, the amount of generating capacity required per-person to qualify for that portion of the aggregate rebate and the fractional ceiling limiting the overall rebate as a proportion of the system's cost.
One big weakness I see here is that it's hard to predict how quickly the scheme would burn through its budget allocation. A possible remedy would be to vary the rebate parameters on a periodic basis - probably as part of each year's federal budget.
So there you go. That's enough of that I think.
Monday, 19 May 2008
About that PV rebate means test
Hi again.
By now I expect you've all heard that in last week's federal budget, the first under this new management, it was announced that the Photovoltaic Rebate Program (PVRP) would immediately be subjected to means testing. Specifically, the $8,000 rebate would not be available to households whose combined income exceeds $100,000 per annum.
Predictably, there's been an enraged outcry from the renewable energy industry and green groups, and of course the opposition parties have seized the opportunity to attack the government's credibility on climate change policy. ("Hi Kettle, I'm Pot! My, you're a lovely black colour aren't you?")
Like many commentators I have great sympathy for the small business owners and employees who've been enjoying a surge in PV installation activity as a direct consequence of the PVRP and who are now dealing with a sudden drop in orders. Yet I do not necessarily agree that the PVRP should have been left as it was. Let me explain.
In the back of your mind you must always remember this: photovoltaic technology is really neat, but it's a long way from ideal. For starters, today's PV is generally more expensive than other renewables. And it only generates power while the Sun is shining brightly. No matter how many solar panels we install in this country we'll always have need for other energy systems which generate significant power for the other 16 hours per day.
As a rule, I was no fan of the former government. So hopefully it should get your attention when I say that the basic premise behind the PVRP was pretty sound. $150M was allocated over five years to encourage industry development and hence further R&D in PV technology - not to generate as much electricity as possible! Maybe they were forced into it, I don't know, but it was a sensible notion to invest public funds in a promising sector of the renewable energy industry. Unfortunately... they didn't follow through with a sensible rebate scheme for the distribution of those funds.
The PVRP previously offered a flat $4,000. Better than a kick in the teeth, but with PV systems starting at around $12K for an average output of 4kWh per day even that wasn't enough to spur a lot of interest. The "battlers" still couldn't afford it and the more well-off could get better rates of financial return from other forms of "investment". So last year, possibly reading the pre-election mood re climate change, they doubled the rebate to $8,000.
Well didn't that just open the floodgates. They halved the effective cost of an entry-level PV system, bringing it within the reach of middle Australia and making the financial payback time far more acceptable. The take-up rate exploded, "with 35% of all solar installed in eight years of the program occurring in the last six months." (Quote from ATA e-bulletin 19 May 2008).
Poor Mr Swan. Elected to government on the promise of leadership on climate change, faced with the economic necessity of slashing government spending, he had to deal with a PVRP that had gotten out of control and was burning through its multi-year budgetary allocation at an alarming rate. There were only two options: put the brakes on the rate at which money was being paid out (by lowering the amount per payment or limiting its availability) or let it continue to accelerate before slamming into a brick wall a little way down the track when the money runs out. Clearly the brick wall option would be catastrophic for the very PV industry which the program was intended to foster.
So the new management decided to slow the rate of payments by introducing a means test, in line with the general policy of targeting financial assistance to those who need it most. In my personal opinion, that was a reasonable thing to do. The biggest thing to criticise is that it's an all-or-nothing measure tacked on to what was a poorly-designed rebate scheme in the first place.
Just for the fun of it I'm going to do a separate post discussing the actual impact of the means test, how it might relate to the also-announced green loans scheme, and explore an alternate design for a PVRP means test.
To wrap up this one, though, I would ask you to keep looking at the bigger picture and reserve your final judgement on this government's climate change credibility until we see their response to the Garnaut review. The PVRP is something that was inherited and that, politically, had to be carefully managed. Failure to slow the rate of payout would have harmed the PV industry and been attacked by the opposition as financially irresponsible. Axing the scheme (presumably in favour of something better down the track) or reducing the rebate would have sparked a political feeding frenzy. It had to be maintained, but carefully.
The Minister for the Environment put it this way on ABC TV: "We've got programs out there... which will ensure there is enough demand in the Australian community in the long term to get solar panels on roofs... and to make sure that we continue to build a sustainable solar industry into the long term."
Mind you, the other climate change measures announced in the budget weren't terribly inspiring... my guess is it'll be another year, the post-Garnaut budget, before we know whether the promised leadership will be delivered. Let's keep up the pressure.
By now I expect you've all heard that in last week's federal budget, the first under this new management, it was announced that the Photovoltaic Rebate Program (PVRP) would immediately be subjected to means testing. Specifically, the $8,000 rebate would not be available to households whose combined income exceeds $100,000 per annum.
Predictably, there's been an enraged outcry from the renewable energy industry and green groups, and of course the opposition parties have seized the opportunity to attack the government's credibility on climate change policy. ("Hi Kettle, I'm Pot! My, you're a lovely black colour aren't you?")
Like many commentators I have great sympathy for the small business owners and employees who've been enjoying a surge in PV installation activity as a direct consequence of the PVRP and who are now dealing with a sudden drop in orders. Yet I do not necessarily agree that the PVRP should have been left as it was. Let me explain.
In the back of your mind you must always remember this: photovoltaic technology is really neat, but it's a long way from ideal. For starters, today's PV is generally more expensive than other renewables. And it only generates power while the Sun is shining brightly. No matter how many solar panels we install in this country we'll always have need for other energy systems which generate significant power for the other 16 hours per day.
As a rule, I was no fan of the former government. So hopefully it should get your attention when I say that the basic premise behind the PVRP was pretty sound. $150M was allocated over five years to encourage industry development and hence further R&D in PV technology - not to generate as much electricity as possible! Maybe they were forced into it, I don't know, but it was a sensible notion to invest public funds in a promising sector of the renewable energy industry. Unfortunately... they didn't follow through with a sensible rebate scheme for the distribution of those funds.
The PVRP previously offered a flat $4,000. Better than a kick in the teeth, but with PV systems starting at around $12K for an average output of 4kWh per day even that wasn't enough to spur a lot of interest. The "battlers" still couldn't afford it and the more well-off could get better rates of financial return from other forms of "investment". So last year, possibly reading the pre-election mood re climate change, they doubled the rebate to $8,000.
Well didn't that just open the floodgates. They halved the effective cost of an entry-level PV system, bringing it within the reach of middle Australia and making the financial payback time far more acceptable. The take-up rate exploded, "with 35% of all solar installed in eight years of the program occurring in the last six months." (Quote from ATA e-bulletin 19 May 2008).
Poor Mr Swan. Elected to government on the promise of leadership on climate change, faced with the economic necessity of slashing government spending, he had to deal with a PVRP that had gotten out of control and was burning through its multi-year budgetary allocation at an alarming rate. There were only two options: put the brakes on the rate at which money was being paid out (by lowering the amount per payment or limiting its availability) or let it continue to accelerate before slamming into a brick wall a little way down the track when the money runs out. Clearly the brick wall option would be catastrophic for the very PV industry which the program was intended to foster.
So the new management decided to slow the rate of payments by introducing a means test, in line with the general policy of targeting financial assistance to those who need it most. In my personal opinion, that was a reasonable thing to do. The biggest thing to criticise is that it's an all-or-nothing measure tacked on to what was a poorly-designed rebate scheme in the first place.
Just for the fun of it I'm going to do a separate post discussing the actual impact of the means test, how it might relate to the also-announced green loans scheme, and explore an alternate design for a PVRP means test.
To wrap up this one, though, I would ask you to keep looking at the bigger picture and reserve your final judgement on this government's climate change credibility until we see their response to the Garnaut review. The PVRP is something that was inherited and that, politically, had to be carefully managed. Failure to slow the rate of payout would have harmed the PV industry and been attacked by the opposition as financially irresponsible. Axing the scheme (presumably in favour of something better down the track) or reducing the rebate would have sparked a political feeding frenzy. It had to be maintained, but carefully.
The Minister for the Environment put it this way on ABC TV: "We've got programs out there... which will ensure there is enough demand in the Australian community in the long term to get solar panels on roofs... and to make sure that we continue to build a sustainable solar industry into the long term."
Mind you, the other climate change measures announced in the budget weren't terribly inspiring... my guess is it'll be another year, the post-Garnaut budget, before we know whether the promised leadership will be delivered. Let's keep up the pressure.
Saturday, 19 April 2008
"Greenwashing" concern re Solahart promotion
I just sent the following email to Solahart's Australian headquarters:
Hello,
Let me preface this by saying that I'm a very satisfied Solahart customer, having replaced my electric system just over six months ago and not wasted a single watt-hour of electricity on water heating ever since. However I was not so impressed with your company's recent marketing initiative involving a bumper sticker which reads, "My Solahart helps offset my car's CO2 emissions."
It surprised and disappointed me to have such a misleading environmental line come from a company which does an enormous amount of good through the promotion of renewable energy technology. Quite simply, that bumper sticker statement is false and potentially harmful.
The statement is false because solar water heaters do not remove CO2 from the atmosphere, directly or indirectly, and therefore cannot be counted as an "offset" against the burning of fossil fuels in a car engine. Instead, solar water heaters simply avoid the need to burn fossil fuels in power stations or in gas heaters. There is absolutely no relationship between solar hot water and vehicle emissions.
If the community truly believed the bumper sticker then they would feel less compelled to reduce their transport-related emissions in the false belief that they were somehow "offset" to some degree by their solar water heater.
Though it may have been an honest mistake or oversight, this promotion has the appearance of "greenwashing". At the very least, please cease the distribution of this bumper sticker immediately. I would also ask that you either send a follow-up retraction letter to all those who have already been sent a sticker (such as myself), or that you post such a retraction in a prominent place on your website or in another suitable public forum.
I would be more than happy to discuss these matters with you further - please feel free to reply via email or contact me on [phone number removed].
Sincerely,
Terry Brady
Bald Hills, Qld, Australia
http://2050vision.blogspot.com
Sunday, 13 April 2008
Solar Tariff Tiff
There's a lot of noise being made at the moment about "feed-in tariffs", or bonus money paid to folks like me for energy that my new solar panels will feed in to the electricity grid. The debate centres around how to measure and price that energy. Here's my take.
There are two main kinds of benefit that large-scale distributed PV electric generation can potentially deliver to the community as a whole: environmental and financial.
The long-term environmental vision, which I'm sure most people would agree is the right idea, is for future society to be powered with cheap, clean, renewable energy instead of being dependent on the burning of coal or the fission of uranium which - even if the technology can be made "clean" - will both eventually run out. An essential feature of this vision is that we must become far more efficient in our use of the energy that is available.
And while it's obvious to most people that harvesting sunlight is sustainable and much cleaner than digging up and burning coal, not everybody is aware that having solar energy generation located nice and close to all our air conditioners is a great way to minimise infrastructure costs associated with peak demand and long-distance power transmission on hot afternoons.
A good feed-in tariff scheme for solar electricity would help to realise both kinds of benefit.
The Queensland Government appears to be following the South Australian lead in proposing a model under which I would only be paid a bonus for producing energy that was not simultaneously consumed within my own home. Just to be clear, that's excess energy which I produce but somebody else gets to use. This is broadly referred to as a "net tariff" scheme.
A number of groups, including the Local Power group through which I've ordered my panels, the Alternative Technology Association, Queensland Conservation, the Queensland Consumers Association and reportedly even BP (who make panels) are expressing disappointment in this and arguing instead for a "gross tariff" scheme whereby I would be paid a premium rate for all the energy produced by my panels regardless of how much energy I consume within my own home, or when. This is reportedly the model implemented in Germany, a world leader in terms of solar electricity generation capacity.
The motivation of the "gross tariff" advocates is fairly simple to understand.
Firstly, most of them genuinely want to see our society move as quickly as possible from fossil-fuel dependency to clean, renewable energy sources - which of course I agree with. Secondly, there's the financial self-interest: panel buyers want faster payback on their "investment" and higher long-term profitability while manufacturers like BP want to sell more panels. And thirdly we have an environmental loopback effect where making panels more financially attractive encourages greater adoption which takes us one step closer to having a clean, renewable energy infrastructure.
However, despite being both an "environmentalist" and a purchaser of solar panels, I don't agree that a gross tariff scheme is an obviously right choice for Queensland as a whole community.
In order to deliver on the environmental potential, the installation of solar panels must succeed in reducing the overall demand for energy from non-renewable sources. And in order to reduce costs associated with the grid infrastructure itelf, that energy must be delivered at times of peak demand. As I see it, the gross tariff schemes being proposed would actually erode both of those benefits from the inside, because it reduces the incentive for the owners of the panels to minimise their own energy consumption. Taken to the extreme, it provides an avenue for wealthy high energy users (and especially those addicted to their air conditioning) to cheaply maintain or even increase their energy consumption. I have actually had conversations with somebody who sees that kind of thing as an opportunity.
(Related post: Does energy efficiency encourage greater consumption?)
In contrast, the net tariff scheme put forward by the state is designed to reward those who find ways to minimise their consumption (delivering the environmental benefit), especially during those hot, sunny times when their panels are producing the most power (delivering the peak load infrastructure cost benefit).
Australian taxpayers are already contributing $8,000 towards my panels through a federal scheme to stimulate growth in the PV industry. Why should my fellow Queenslanders pay me even more in a subsidy which I could squander by simply using more energy and defeating the purpose of all that investment in the first place?
---
Speaking of the bigger picture, I believe that the actual core problem here is that current retail energy prices are much, much lower than the true cost of the energy. Government subsidies to the coal industry, myopic belief in unlimited growth and a very bad habit of completely ignoring "externalities" have made it so. Gross tariff proposals make a certain amount of sense in that they come closer to recognising the complete value of the energy, but the proper objectives of such a scheme would be continually undermined by the disincentive to reduce consumption.
Maybe as a kind of middle-ground policy it would make sense for panel owners to be paid a modest flat rate for their gross production on the proviso that they sourced at least the same quantity of energy (or 100% of their consumption, whichever is lower) from GreenPower-accredited providers. That would help to direct funding into renewable energy projects. Mind you, panel owners could achieve almost exactly the same thing by simply not selling their RECs at the time of installation. (See my earlier post on that topic.)
Perhaps surprisingly, I'm leaning towards opposing "time-of-day" metering for retail electricity consumption at this point. The idea behind it is to charge consumers more for energy consumed during peak periods. Sounds sensible enough, but apart from smoothing the load on the distribution grid it actually favours the coal generators and erodes the benefit of having a substantial PV capacity. However if it could be shown that time-of-day metering reduced overall energy consumption and especially consumption of fossil fuels then it might be worth doing.
But the "elephant in the room" (to borrow a phrase I once heard used by Andrew McNamara) which apparently nobody is talking about is that over the lifetime of any new solar panel installation the retail price of energy is likely to go up dramatically. You can thank climate change, carbon trading, peak oil and population growth for that. Even without any kind of tariffs, that rise should significantly shorten the effective payback time for a PV installation through avoided energy costs in the future.
There are two main kinds of benefit that large-scale distributed PV electric generation can potentially deliver to the community as a whole: environmental and financial.
The long-term environmental vision, which I'm sure most people would agree is the right idea, is for future society to be powered with cheap, clean, renewable energy instead of being dependent on the burning of coal or the fission of uranium which - even if the technology can be made "clean" - will both eventually run out. An essential feature of this vision is that we must become far more efficient in our use of the energy that is available.
And while it's obvious to most people that harvesting sunlight is sustainable and much cleaner than digging up and burning coal, not everybody is aware that having solar energy generation located nice and close to all our air conditioners is a great way to minimise infrastructure costs associated with peak demand and long-distance power transmission on hot afternoons.
A good feed-in tariff scheme for solar electricity would help to realise both kinds of benefit.
The Queensland Government appears to be following the South Australian lead in proposing a model under which I would only be paid a bonus for producing energy that was not simultaneously consumed within my own home. Just to be clear, that's excess energy which I produce but somebody else gets to use. This is broadly referred to as a "net tariff" scheme.
A number of groups, including the Local Power group through which I've ordered my panels, the Alternative Technology Association, Queensland Conservation, the Queensland Consumers Association and reportedly even BP (who make panels) are expressing disappointment in this and arguing instead for a "gross tariff" scheme whereby I would be paid a premium rate for all the energy produced by my panels regardless of how much energy I consume within my own home, or when. This is reportedly the model implemented in Germany, a world leader in terms of solar electricity generation capacity.
The motivation of the "gross tariff" advocates is fairly simple to understand.
Firstly, most of them genuinely want to see our society move as quickly as possible from fossil-fuel dependency to clean, renewable energy sources - which of course I agree with. Secondly, there's the financial self-interest: panel buyers want faster payback on their "investment" and higher long-term profitability while manufacturers like BP want to sell more panels. And thirdly we have an environmental loopback effect where making panels more financially attractive encourages greater adoption which takes us one step closer to having a clean, renewable energy infrastructure.
However, despite being both an "environmentalist" and a purchaser of solar panels, I don't agree that a gross tariff scheme is an obviously right choice for Queensland as a whole community.
In order to deliver on the environmental potential, the installation of solar panels must succeed in reducing the overall demand for energy from non-renewable sources. And in order to reduce costs associated with the grid infrastructure itelf, that energy must be delivered at times of peak demand. As I see it, the gross tariff schemes being proposed would actually erode both of those benefits from the inside, because it reduces the incentive for the owners of the panels to minimise their own energy consumption. Taken to the extreme, it provides an avenue for wealthy high energy users (and especially those addicted to their air conditioning) to cheaply maintain or even increase their energy consumption. I have actually had conversations with somebody who sees that kind of thing as an opportunity.
(Related post: Does energy efficiency encourage greater consumption?)
In contrast, the net tariff scheme put forward by the state is designed to reward those who find ways to minimise their consumption (delivering the environmental benefit), especially during those hot, sunny times when their panels are producing the most power (delivering the peak load infrastructure cost benefit).
Australian taxpayers are already contributing $8,000 towards my panels through a federal scheme to stimulate growth in the PV industry. Why should my fellow Queenslanders pay me even more in a subsidy which I could squander by simply using more energy and defeating the purpose of all that investment in the first place?
---
Speaking of the bigger picture, I believe that the actual core problem here is that current retail energy prices are much, much lower than the true cost of the energy. Government subsidies to the coal industry, myopic belief in unlimited growth and a very bad habit of completely ignoring "externalities" have made it so. Gross tariff proposals make a certain amount of sense in that they come closer to recognising the complete value of the energy, but the proper objectives of such a scheme would be continually undermined by the disincentive to reduce consumption.
Maybe as a kind of middle-ground policy it would make sense for panel owners to be paid a modest flat rate for their gross production on the proviso that they sourced at least the same quantity of energy (or 100% of their consumption, whichever is lower) from GreenPower-accredited providers. That would help to direct funding into renewable energy projects. Mind you, panel owners could achieve almost exactly the same thing by simply not selling their RECs at the time of installation. (See my earlier post on that topic.)
Perhaps surprisingly, I'm leaning towards opposing "time-of-day" metering for retail electricity consumption at this point. The idea behind it is to charge consumers more for energy consumed during peak periods. Sounds sensible enough, but apart from smoothing the load on the distribution grid it actually favours the coal generators and erodes the benefit of having a substantial PV capacity. However if it could be shown that time-of-day metering reduced overall energy consumption and especially consumption of fossil fuels then it might be worth doing.
But the "elephant in the room" (to borrow a phrase I once heard used by Andrew McNamara) which apparently nobody is talking about is that over the lifetime of any new solar panel installation the retail price of energy is likely to go up dramatically. You can thank climate change, carbon trading, peak oil and population growth for that. Even without any kind of tariffs, that rise should significantly shorten the effective payback time for a PV installation through avoided energy costs in the future.
Labels:
behaviour,
coal,
consumption,
economics,
efficiency,
energy,
policy,
population,
renewable,
solar,
vision
Tuesday, 11 March 2008
Queenslanders receive cash incentive to tackle climate change
Update 13/4: Most of what I wrote in this post still makes sense, except that the actual model proposed by the government is slightly different to what I though it was. See today's post for more detail.
---
Great headline, huh? I can't claim credit for it - somebody in the Premier's Office came up with that one to catch the media's attention for today's press release about feed-in tariffs for private solar electricity generation. (Thanks to Ian for pointing that one out to me.)
Like most government statements there's enough spin there to make you dizzy just looking at it. The goods news is that behind the bluster is some really good policy. And a catch, of course.
The announcement lauds the Queensland government's decision to "pay households and business 44 cents for every kilowatt-hour generated from solar power systems at work and at home and fed into the grid." At first glance it sounds like every panel on every roof suddenly becomes a great money-spinner. However you need to read carefully into the definition of "fed into the grid." In the context of the rest of the release it becomes clear that the 44c rate applies only to any additional energy produced by the panels in excess of the energy consumed by the household or business. Your panels have to make more energy than you use before the government (or utilities) spend a cent.
You'd know by now that I'm quite proud of my home's energy efficiency. Our bill just arrived confirming our consumption for the quarter at 7.8kWh per day. (By comparison, Australian government figures I found via Google seem to suggest that the average Aussie household uses around 18, and some friends of ours just got hit with a bill for something in the vicinity of 50kWh per day.) To produce enough energy to meet all of my own needs in a year, I would need to install a 2kW (peak output) array which is estimated to produce almost exactly 8kWh per day on average. Even with the discount negotiated by the Local Power buying group and the federal govt's eight grand rebate I'd be looking at an investment of around $11,000 just to get my quarterly bill down to zero!
If I wanted to actually get some of the 44c/kWh action I'd need to install an even larger 3kW array - an additional investment of 7 thousand for a yearly return of around $650. Premier Bligh's offer doesn't sound quite so generous now, does it?
So I need to explain why I said at the top of this that it's "really good policy". Thankfully the explanation is simple: this policy promotes interest and investment in renewable energy infrastructure, but more importantly it provides a strong incentive to increase efficiency and reduce demand in order to get household or business consumption down below the capacity of smaller PV systems which are presently affordable thanks to the federal government's $8K rebate scheme. For myself, I'll be taking the 4kWh per day threshold as a personal challenge.
Though I may have to wait until the kids leave home before that becomes feasible. Good thing the feed-in tariff legislation announced today is guaranteed for 20 years.
---
Great headline, huh? I can't claim credit for it - somebody in the Premier's Office came up with that one to catch the media's attention for today's press release about feed-in tariffs for private solar electricity generation. (Thanks to Ian for pointing that one out to me.)
Like most government statements there's enough spin there to make you dizzy just looking at it. The goods news is that behind the bluster is some really good policy. And a catch, of course.
The announcement lauds the Queensland government's decision to "pay households and business 44 cents for every kilowatt-hour generated from solar power systems at work and at home and fed into the grid." At first glance it sounds like every panel on every roof suddenly becomes a great money-spinner. However you need to read carefully into the definition of "fed into the grid." In the context of the rest of the release it becomes clear that the 44c rate applies only to any additional energy produced by the panels in excess of the energy consumed by the household or business. Your panels have to make more energy than you use before the government (or utilities) spend a cent.
You'd know by now that I'm quite proud of my home's energy efficiency. Our bill just arrived confirming our consumption for the quarter at 7.8kWh per day. (By comparison, Australian government figures I found via Google seem to suggest that the average Aussie household uses around 18, and some friends of ours just got hit with a bill for something in the vicinity of 50kWh per day.) To produce enough energy to meet all of my own needs in a year, I would need to install a 2kW (peak output) array which is estimated to produce almost exactly 8kWh per day on average. Even with the discount negotiated by the Local Power buying group and the federal govt's eight grand rebate I'd be looking at an investment of around $11,000 just to get my quarterly bill down to zero!
If I wanted to actually get some of the 44c/kWh action I'd need to install an even larger 3kW array - an additional investment of 7 thousand for a yearly return of around $650. Premier Bligh's offer doesn't sound quite so generous now, does it?
So I need to explain why I said at the top of this that it's "really good policy". Thankfully the explanation is simple: this policy promotes interest and investment in renewable energy infrastructure, but more importantly it provides a strong incentive to increase efficiency and reduce demand in order to get household or business consumption down below the capacity of smaller PV systems which are presently affordable thanks to the federal government's $8K rebate scheme. For myself, I'll be taking the 4kWh per day threshold as a personal challenge.
Though I may have to wait until the kids leave home before that becomes feasible. Good thing the feed-in tariff legislation announced today is guaranteed for 20 years.
Labels:
consumption,
efficiency,
energy,
policy,
solar
Sunday, 9 March 2008
Can't have your solar power cake and eat it too
Let me first give kudos to the people behind Local Power, a community-based buying group which is helping to bring a chunk of new solar electricity generation online. I applaud their initiative, commitment and professionalism. More than that, though, I've paid them a deposit to have a 1kW photovoltaic array installed on my own roof.
Curiously, following on the heels of the high levels of public interest in what this group has done, the Queensland government has announced that it will offer a similar kind of service in order to facilitate the installation of a thousand PV systems on roofs in the "sunshine state" at a reduced price. Note they're not actually providing funds for the gear - just the administrative service that's required to coordinate a bulk purchase and therefore a cheaper per-unit price.
I'll leave my thoughts about the significance and value of PV in the grand scheme of things for another post. For this one I want to focus on a tricky little aspect which green-minded solar panel buyers will need to be aware of. (The particulars are likely to vary in different situations but what I'm writing here is what I understand will apply to me. I'll edit and/or post again if I need to.)
Both the Local Power and Qld government schemes are for "grid-connected" solar photovoltaic electricity generating systems. The systems include an inverter which takes the low-voltage DC power from the panels and transforms it into 240V AC power that gets fed into the electricity grid. There's a dedicated meter which measures how much power your system has supplied to the grid, separate from the one you already have which measures how much power you consume in the running of your home.
Hypothetically, let's say that in some future 3 month period my home consumes 675kWh of energy and my panels supply 360kWh to the grid. As I understand it, when I get my electric utility bill I will see the readings for both meters. Normally Tariff 1 costs about 15.5c per kWh so without the panels I'd be charged about $105 for my energy. But with the panels producing power I get recognition for their contribution with a simple deduction from my Tariff 11 consumption. The nett use would be 315kWh at around $49.
Woohoo! My investment in panels has not only saved me money, but reduced my dependence on fossil fuels by 360kWh this quarter! I can sure feel proud of myself now, having invested in environmental protection and sustainability.
But wait a moment. I might be badly mistaken about my green energy credentials.
You see, most of the time when a PV system like this gets installed, the buyer signs a little bit of paper in return for an extra discount on the up-front cost. The amount of the discount varies but as an example the system I've ordered might be discounted by somewhere between $315 and $819. Neat, huh? How nice of the government to give me a bit of an extra bonus for investing in clean energy.
Listen up: this is not a bonus. This is not free money. The form that you are offered to sign is one which transfers your right to claim the "cleanness" of the energy your panels will produce over their lifetime to another party. You are paid market price for your Renewable Energy Certificates, or "RECs" as they are known. One REC is equivalent to one megawatt-hour (MWh) of renewable power. These RECs represent the legal right of the holder to claim that the power they used (or sold to somebody else) was clean. And if you signed that paper, you don't have them any more.
So in the case of my hypothetical electricity bill, though I do enjoy a financial benefit, every one of the 675kWh of energy that I consumed must have been supplied to the grid by coal-fired power stations! If I wanted to have a clear conscience about my energy use I'd still have to opt in for 675kWh of 100% certified GreenPower. In effect I would have to pay a bit extra each quarter to buy a portion of my own original RECs back again.
I hope that's not too confusing. Just to repeat: by selling my RECs when the system was installed, I gave up the right to claim the cleanliness of the energy my system produces. Though I get a financial benefit for the energy produced by the system over time, I would still have to opt in to GreenPower schemes for the entire amount of my personal energy consumption if I want to eliminate my dependence on dirty power generators.
It's worth pointing out that you're in no way obliged to sell your RECs. You can either hold on to them with a view to eventually selling them (during which time you would have to pay the GreenPower surcharge since you're intending to give up your right to the cleanliness of your panels' energy sometime in the future) or your can ignore the whole scheme entirely and just consider all of that clean energy to be yours for as long as you're using the panels. Whatever you do, there's a bit of a gamble and speculation involved and most of us don't have the time nor skill to track and trade these things to our financial benefit.
So if you do sign up for one of these systems - which I would generally applaud even though I think PV is only a tiny part of the overall solution to our energy and climate crisis - please be aware of the significance of the RECs scheme and what it means to sell those certificates. Otherwise you might end up being more dependent on fossil fuels than you hoped you would be, without even realising it.
Curiously, following on the heels of the high levels of public interest in what this group has done, the Queensland government has announced that it will offer a similar kind of service in order to facilitate the installation of a thousand PV systems on roofs in the "sunshine state" at a reduced price. Note they're not actually providing funds for the gear - just the administrative service that's required to coordinate a bulk purchase and therefore a cheaper per-unit price.
I'll leave my thoughts about the significance and value of PV in the grand scheme of things for another post. For this one I want to focus on a tricky little aspect which green-minded solar panel buyers will need to be aware of. (The particulars are likely to vary in different situations but what I'm writing here is what I understand will apply to me. I'll edit and/or post again if I need to.)
Both the Local Power and Qld government schemes are for "grid-connected" solar photovoltaic electricity generating systems. The systems include an inverter which takes the low-voltage DC power from the panels and transforms it into 240V AC power that gets fed into the electricity grid. There's a dedicated meter which measures how much power your system has supplied to the grid, separate from the one you already have which measures how much power you consume in the running of your home.
Hypothetically, let's say that in some future 3 month period my home consumes 675kWh of energy and my panels supply 360kWh to the grid. As I understand it, when I get my electric utility bill I will see the readings for both meters. Normally Tariff 1 costs about 15.5c per kWh so without the panels I'd be charged about $105 for my energy. But with the panels producing power I get recognition for their contribution with a simple deduction from my Tariff 11 consumption. The nett use would be 315kWh at around $49.
Woohoo! My investment in panels has not only saved me money, but reduced my dependence on fossil fuels by 360kWh this quarter! I can sure feel proud of myself now, having invested in environmental protection and sustainability.
But wait a moment. I might be badly mistaken about my green energy credentials.
You see, most of the time when a PV system like this gets installed, the buyer signs a little bit of paper in return for an extra discount on the up-front cost. The amount of the discount varies but as an example the system I've ordered might be discounted by somewhere between $315 and $819. Neat, huh? How nice of the government to give me a bit of an extra bonus for investing in clean energy.
Listen up: this is not a bonus. This is not free money. The form that you are offered to sign is one which transfers your right to claim the "cleanness" of the energy your panels will produce over their lifetime to another party. You are paid market price for your Renewable Energy Certificates, or "RECs" as they are known. One REC is equivalent to one megawatt-hour (MWh) of renewable power. These RECs represent the legal right of the holder to claim that the power they used (or sold to somebody else) was clean. And if you signed that paper, you don't have them any more.
So in the case of my hypothetical electricity bill, though I do enjoy a financial benefit, every one of the 675kWh of energy that I consumed must have been supplied to the grid by coal-fired power stations! If I wanted to have a clear conscience about my energy use I'd still have to opt in for 675kWh of 100% certified GreenPower. In effect I would have to pay a bit extra each quarter to buy a portion of my own original RECs back again.
I hope that's not too confusing. Just to repeat: by selling my RECs when the system was installed, I gave up the right to claim the cleanliness of the energy my system produces. Though I get a financial benefit for the energy produced by the system over time, I would still have to opt in to GreenPower schemes for the entire amount of my personal energy consumption if I want to eliminate my dependence on dirty power generators.
It's worth pointing out that you're in no way obliged to sell your RECs. You can either hold on to them with a view to eventually selling them (during which time you would have to pay the GreenPower surcharge since you're intending to give up your right to the cleanliness of your panels' energy sometime in the future) or your can ignore the whole scheme entirely and just consider all of that clean energy to be yours for as long as you're using the panels. Whatever you do, there's a bit of a gamble and speculation involved and most of us don't have the time nor skill to track and trade these things to our financial benefit.
So if you do sign up for one of these systems - which I would generally applaud even though I think PV is only a tiny part of the overall solution to our energy and climate crisis - please be aware of the significance of the RECs scheme and what it means to sell those certificates. Otherwise you might end up being more dependent on fossil fuels than you hoped you would be, without even realising it.
Labels:
community action,
energy,
policy,
renewable,
solar
Friday, 21 September 2007
Money and power
This past week has had a fairly clear theme for me: the price of energy. There's the record-breaking crude oil prices, a discussion at our BNCWAG meeting about the confusing options for buying renewable electricity and then of course the replacement of our hot water system with a solar one.
Lets leave the oil issue alone for the moment (partly because the record prices are being kicked along by a weak US dollar which reduces the significance of the raw numbers). Just now I'm more interested in the electricity market.
Here in Queensland the energy market is regulated. There are fixed tariffs for the supply of electricity to various types of customers for various purposes. Most homes have two circuits: one which supplies electricity for general domestic purposes 24 hours a day for roughly 15c per kWh, and another which typically is connected to a water heater but only works during off-peak hours and is billed at a much lower rate (as low as about 6.5c per kWh).
These prices are the new ones, following an increase at the start of July which was largely attributed to the rising cost of producing electricity with cooling water being in short supply due to the drought. Ironically the drought conditions have led to a significant reduction in shower times and a corresponding reduction in the amount of water heating required. My most recent figures have us averaging 7.3kWh per day this winter at a cost of around 47c.
Now here's the bit which is bugging me. If my shiny new solar hot water system was so good that it never needed any electrical boosting (it's not), and assuming that we required that same amount of heating all year round (we don't), it would take just shy of 30 years for us to recoup the cost of the new unit from the savings on our electricity bills.
I can imagine my wife's raised eyebrow and my father's shaking head about now. But even having run these numbers I would still make the same decision again. It's only bugging me because it makes it harder to convince other people that it's a decision they'd want to make too. There are three reasons I want to point out here.
1. This is mostly about saving energy, not money
The pursuit of short-term economic advantage is what led to our current dirty coal infrastructure and is what maintains the hegemony of the coal industry in Australia's energy industry.
The reason that electricity is available at less than half price overnight is that the massive steam turbines in the coal-fired power plants cannot be switched on and off in a daily cycle. The operators of these plants need to smooth out the demand curve over the course of the day and these skewed pricing arrangements help them achieve that by encouraging additional energy consumption during the night.
It works too: this past quarter my water heater used more energy than everything else in the rest of the house combined! Though it will reduce our bill by less than 30% and at these prices will never pay for itself, installing a solar hot water system is going to approximately halve our total electricity consumption.
2. Electricity prices are likely to rise sharply - even for dirty coal.
There are a number of pressures on the electricity market which I suspect will cause prices to rise sharply over the next couple of decades. If you forgot about sustainability concerns completely you'd still have decreasing availability of cooling water, increasing global demand for coal, increasing local demand for electricity and the need for infrastructure work on generation and transmission.
Now I do hope that the sustainability and environmental agenda is going to have a powerful influence on future policy and development. This would lead to greater reliance on wind and other renewables which have a lower overall capacity, generally higher cost (than the present price of coal where many costs are subsidised or simply not accounted for) and a different delivery profile (solar, for example, is obviously linked to daily cycles).
All in all I expect the price of a unit of energy for the end user like you and me is going nowhere but up. Hopefully through a range of efficiency measures we can keep our overall costs from rising. My Solahart might turn out to be an economic winner in the future.
3. It's in keeping with the philosophy of sustainable design
I keep thinking back to McDonough's work on architecture and building design and his philosophy of making the best use of the available natural resources. Without the solar water heater up there the sunlight's energy would be wasted. My vision for the future is nowhere near as vivid as McDonough's but I'm quite certain that I'd expect to see solar heating in a place like Brisbane.
Lets leave the oil issue alone for the moment (partly because the record prices are being kicked along by a weak US dollar which reduces the significance of the raw numbers). Just now I'm more interested in the electricity market.
Here in Queensland the energy market is regulated. There are fixed tariffs for the supply of electricity to various types of customers for various purposes. Most homes have two circuits: one which supplies electricity for general domestic purposes 24 hours a day for roughly 15c per kWh, and another which typically is connected to a water heater but only works during off-peak hours and is billed at a much lower rate (as low as about 6.5c per kWh).
These prices are the new ones, following an increase at the start of July which was largely attributed to the rising cost of producing electricity with cooling water being in short supply due to the drought. Ironically the drought conditions have led to a significant reduction in shower times and a corresponding reduction in the amount of water heating required. My most recent figures have us averaging 7.3kWh per day this winter at a cost of around 47c.
Now here's the bit which is bugging me. If my shiny new solar hot water system was so good that it never needed any electrical boosting (it's not), and assuming that we required that same amount of heating all year round (we don't), it would take just shy of 30 years for us to recoup the cost of the new unit from the savings on our electricity bills.
I can imagine my wife's raised eyebrow and my father's shaking head about now. But even having run these numbers I would still make the same decision again. It's only bugging me because it makes it harder to convince other people that it's a decision they'd want to make too. There are three reasons I want to point out here.
1. This is mostly about saving energy, not money
The pursuit of short-term economic advantage is what led to our current dirty coal infrastructure and is what maintains the hegemony of the coal industry in Australia's energy industry.
The reason that electricity is available at less than half price overnight is that the massive steam turbines in the coal-fired power plants cannot be switched on and off in a daily cycle. The operators of these plants need to smooth out the demand curve over the course of the day and these skewed pricing arrangements help them achieve that by encouraging additional energy consumption during the night.
It works too: this past quarter my water heater used more energy than everything else in the rest of the house combined! Though it will reduce our bill by less than 30% and at these prices will never pay for itself, installing a solar hot water system is going to approximately halve our total electricity consumption.
2. Electricity prices are likely to rise sharply - even for dirty coal.
There are a number of pressures on the electricity market which I suspect will cause prices to rise sharply over the next couple of decades. If you forgot about sustainability concerns completely you'd still have decreasing availability of cooling water, increasing global demand for coal, increasing local demand for electricity and the need for infrastructure work on generation and transmission.
Now I do hope that the sustainability and environmental agenda is going to have a powerful influence on future policy and development. This would lead to greater reliance on wind and other renewables which have a lower overall capacity, generally higher cost (than the present price of coal where many costs are subsidised or simply not accounted for) and a different delivery profile (solar, for example, is obviously linked to daily cycles).
All in all I expect the price of a unit of energy for the end user like you and me is going nowhere but up. Hopefully through a range of efficiency measures we can keep our overall costs from rising. My Solahart might turn out to be an economic winner in the future.
3. It's in keeping with the philosophy of sustainable design
I keep thinking back to McDonough's work on architecture and building design and his philosophy of making the best use of the available natural resources. Without the solar water heater up there the sunlight's energy would be wasted. My vision for the future is nowhere near as vivid as McDonough's but I'm quite certain that I'd expect to see solar heating in a place like Brisbane.
Sunshine on tap
True to their word, the Solahart mob came and installed our new water heater today. The tank was only filled mid-afternoon so it's not had a chance to capture much sun yet and the water coming out of the tap is merely tepid. We've got the electric booster switch turned on tonight so that we can have a shower in the morning, but hopefully tomorrow night the kids will be enjoying the warmth of the sun after dark as they take their bath.
Tuesday, 18 September 2007
He was only 19... now where's the new kid?
There was a death in the household today. Finally!
Our hulking great electric-storage hot water system sprung a leak this morning after spending 19 years turning one of the most useful forms of energy into one of the least. Hooray and good riddance.
It was a bit of fun in a way. The silly thing was installed inside (presumably so we didn't lose too much heat during Brisbane's biting winters...?) which meant that a sudden leak was something of an emergency. Had to try and shut off the water coming into it and hold open the valves to let as much water as possible escape through the overflow pipe instead of onto the laundry floor. Then discovered that the inlet shut-off tap, which probably hadn't been used in nearly 20 years, just didn't work. The only way to stop the water from flowing was to turn it off at the mains.
Right about then I called Solahart and booked a guy to come out and see us ASAP, which was originally defined as 4:30pm but ended up being closer to 6 after he forgot and I had to chase him up. Oh well, these things happen. In the meantime I had to restore mains water for all our other needs like drinking and flushing the toilet - I ended up removing the inlet tap completely and sealing off that pipe with a brass cap that set me back the princely sum of one hundred and five cents.
I was surprised in the end by the advice we received and the product we ended up ordering. The bloke said that in a place like Brisbane which gets so much sun you should actually avoid buying the most thermally-efficient solar water heaters because for much of the summer you'll end up with water being heated to boiling point, which means a whole lot of water being released down the drain and being completely wasted. With that in mind and having given due consideration to the orientation of our house and the load-bearing capacity of the roof, we're getting a 300L roof-mounted model from the lower-end "L Series".
Because of the weight distribution it'll be mounted flat on the roof facing slightly north of west instead of on a riser which would have had it facing slightly east of north. To compensate for the reduced exposure to the sun it'll have three collector panels instead of the usual two.
If we're lucky it'll be installed before the weekend.
Our hulking great electric-storage hot water system sprung a leak this morning after spending 19 years turning one of the most useful forms of energy into one of the least. Hooray and good riddance.
It was a bit of fun in a way. The silly thing was installed inside (presumably so we didn't lose too much heat during Brisbane's biting winters...?) which meant that a sudden leak was something of an emergency. Had to try and shut off the water coming into it and hold open the valves to let as much water as possible escape through the overflow pipe instead of onto the laundry floor. Then discovered that the inlet shut-off tap, which probably hadn't been used in nearly 20 years, just didn't work. The only way to stop the water from flowing was to turn it off at the mains.
Right about then I called Solahart and booked a guy to come out and see us ASAP, which was originally defined as 4:30pm but ended up being closer to 6 after he forgot and I had to chase him up. Oh well, these things happen. In the meantime I had to restore mains water for all our other needs like drinking and flushing the toilet - I ended up removing the inlet tap completely and sealing off that pipe with a brass cap that set me back the princely sum of one hundred and five cents.
Because of the weight distribution it'll be mounted flat on the roof facing slightly north of west instead of on a riser which would have had it facing slightly east of north. To compensate for the reduced exposure to the sun it'll have three collector panels instead of the usual two.
If we're lucky it'll be installed before the weekend.
Tuesday, 5 June 2007
Understanding Energy - Part 2 of 2
Yesterday's bottom line was this: all the Earth's energy comes from the Sun, it provides life with the ability to grow and to modify the materials of the Earth, and the majority of it eventually heads back out into space as waste heat.
The ancient civilisations of places like Egypt and South America seemed to understand this much better than we do today. Modern man knows clever words like "photosynthesis" but has lost the deep understanding that the Sun is ultimately what puts leaves on the trees and life in our bones.
My best guess at why this is comes down to the discovery of fire, and of "non-living" things which could be burned. Of course I'm referring to coal, oil and natural gas.
Fire is a chemical reaction in which energy that was previously holding atoms together to form molecules is released as heat. Because there's a high concentration of heat energy in one place it's possible for us to channel some of it into causing desirable changes (such as pushing a piston in an engine, melting metal in a furnace or cooking food on a BBQ) before it dissipates and becomes "lost".
For many thousands of years the primary source of chemical energy which humans could harness by setting it alight was wood. Trees spend years soaking up solar energy and converting it to chemical energy that holds together the atoms which form the molecules that comprise its living tissues. At this level the connection between the Sun and the energy available to us in a wood fire is still somewhat intuitive. It's fairly obvious that the trees have to grow before they can be burned.
But coal, oil and gas don't have that same obvious relationship to the Sun. Instead of waiting for a tree to grow you can just dig them up and burn them. And what's more, the amount of chemical energy they contain is far greater than in their equivalent weight of wood. The industrial revolution was unleashed upon the world when people started to figure out more sophisticated ways of using that stored chemical energy to cause changes in materials and motion. That revolution never stopped - we are still living it at full throttle today.
There's just one little problem. Do you remember the two rules of the energy game from yesterday's post?
1. Energy cannot be created or destroyed.
2. Whenever energy is used, some of it gets "lost" and can't be used again.
All that energy in oil didn't just magically appear. Scientists are pretty darn sure that coal and oil and natural gas were formed from the accumulation, over hundreds of millions of years, of solar energy converted by plants into chemical energy and then trapped underground in landslides, floods or similar events. That's why they're called "fossil fuels".
It's like the Earth has an internal rechargeable battery. It's capable of storing an unimaginable amount of energy, and it's in a form which is wonderfully convenient for us to use. It took hundreds of millions of years to charge it up, but in the span of a couple of hundred years we've managed to run the battery down to about 50% charge remaining and at this rate it'll be fully exhausted by about the end of this century.
Let me say that again. We've consumed hundreds of millions of years worth of stored solar energy in just a few centuries, and now we're starting to run out.
The discussion about how much fossil fuel energy remains to be dug up and burned is a complicated one and is made worse by the unfortunate side-effect that we call climate change. I'm going to side-step the whole question of exactly when fossil fuels will cease to be able to meet our energy needs for transport and electricity production - but it will inevitably happen. In many parts of the world energy supply is already struggling to keep pace with demand.
But what else is there?
Governments and corporations the world over are turning to "biofuels" to try and compensate for falling oil production. But the math just doesn't add up: the rate of conversion from sunlight to chemical energy is far too slow to allow it to meet the current demand for oil. Besides which, studies seem to show that in many cases you use about as much oil producing the crop (for powering farm machinery etc) as you get back from the crop in the final product, making the whole enterprise a waste of oil and food at this point in time. Technological advances may make the process more efficient in the future, though, so continued research is worthwhile.
Solar photovoltaic technology - which uses tricks of physics to convert sunlight falling on a substance directly into electricity - has a similar problem. The technology keeps getting better but there's a limited amount of the raw materials needed to make the panels and producing them consumes significant amounts of energy. We probably can't produce enough of them and they don't give back enough energy to make them a silver bullet solution to our electricity dependency, but again more research is needed.
Heating water with solar collectors is a no-brainer and I applaud moves from the Queensland government to phase out the old electric-powered type. Wish it would happen sooner.
Using wind to generate electricty (converting kinetic energy from the moving air into electrical energy in the turbine) is also a pretty smart idea. The wind moves because the Sun heats the air, so tapping into that energy flow is sustainable in the true sense of the word. There are some concerns about the amount of energy used in construction vs the amount of energy the turbine can harness over its lifetime, but those issues can probably be solved through engineering.
Hydro-electric systems are also driven by the Sun. It's the Sun which heats the water and causes it to evaporate. It's the Sun which drives the wind that carries the vapour up over the higher land, imbuing it with gravitational potential energy. As the water flows down again towards sea level we can extract some of that energy to turn a turbine and convert it to electricity.
Wave and/or tidal energy. Waves are caused by the wind, which in turn is powered by the Sun, and there's a colossal amount of kinetic energy in the movement of the water. Harnessing that's a great idea. The tides are due to the gravitational pull of the Moon on the water. Taking energy from that system will actually cause the Moon to orbit more slowly and crash into Earth... but that's going to happen eventually anyway and it's unlikely we'll make any significant impact. (No pun intended.)
Geothermal (hot rocks). Not, strictly speaking, a renewable resource but definitely a clean one. Worth looking at where the geology is appropriate.
Nuclear. Ah, had to get to this eventually. Ultimately, nuclear energy is a form of stored energy that was locked into atoms by long-dead stars. It's completely natural but - like molten lava or the Sydney funnelweb spider - not something you want to get too close to. It's interesting to note that some of the geothermal heat which people want to harness was actually released during the radioactive decay of unstable nuclei. There is a lot of nuclear energy available to us here on Earth but like fossil fuels there are undesirable side-effects and it's not a renewable resource.
And that, pretty much, is it. We need to stop using fossil fuels now due to global warming but we will simply run out of oil soon anyway. Nuclear technology will continue to play a role in the global energy mix for a very long time, and it's possible that new developments could greatly reduce the risks associated with radioactive waste and other concerns. The rest of them are all important because none of them can supply so much energy in such a convenient form as fossil fuels have done for the past couple of centuries.
There's a lot of work needed to secure energy supplies and maintain a habitable planet, even just for the rest of this century. I've started doing my bit and you can too.
Thanks so much for reading this far. Questions, comments, corrections all are welcome.
The ancient civilisations of places like Egypt and South America seemed to understand this much better than we do today. Modern man knows clever words like "photosynthesis" but has lost the deep understanding that the Sun is ultimately what puts leaves on the trees and life in our bones.
My best guess at why this is comes down to the discovery of fire, and of "non-living" things which could be burned. Of course I'm referring to coal, oil and natural gas.
Fire is a chemical reaction in which energy that was previously holding atoms together to form molecules is released as heat. Because there's a high concentration of heat energy in one place it's possible for us to channel some of it into causing desirable changes (such as pushing a piston in an engine, melting metal in a furnace or cooking food on a BBQ) before it dissipates and becomes "lost".
For many thousands of years the primary source of chemical energy which humans could harness by setting it alight was wood. Trees spend years soaking up solar energy and converting it to chemical energy that holds together the atoms which form the molecules that comprise its living tissues. At this level the connection between the Sun and the energy available to us in a wood fire is still somewhat intuitive. It's fairly obvious that the trees have to grow before they can be burned.
But coal, oil and gas don't have that same obvious relationship to the Sun. Instead of waiting for a tree to grow you can just dig them up and burn them. And what's more, the amount of chemical energy they contain is far greater than in their equivalent weight of wood. The industrial revolution was unleashed upon the world when people started to figure out more sophisticated ways of using that stored chemical energy to cause changes in materials and motion. That revolution never stopped - we are still living it at full throttle today.
There's just one little problem. Do you remember the two rules of the energy game from yesterday's post?
1. Energy cannot be created or destroyed.
2. Whenever energy is used, some of it gets "lost" and can't be used again.
All that energy in oil didn't just magically appear. Scientists are pretty darn sure that coal and oil and natural gas were formed from the accumulation, over hundreds of millions of years, of solar energy converted by plants into chemical energy and then trapped underground in landslides, floods or similar events. That's why they're called "fossil fuels".
It's like the Earth has an internal rechargeable battery. It's capable of storing an unimaginable amount of energy, and it's in a form which is wonderfully convenient for us to use. It took hundreds of millions of years to charge it up, but in the span of a couple of hundred years we've managed to run the battery down to about 50% charge remaining and at this rate it'll be fully exhausted by about the end of this century.
Let me say that again. We've consumed hundreds of millions of years worth of stored solar energy in just a few centuries, and now we're starting to run out.
The discussion about how much fossil fuel energy remains to be dug up and burned is a complicated one and is made worse by the unfortunate side-effect that we call climate change. I'm going to side-step the whole question of exactly when fossil fuels will cease to be able to meet our energy needs for transport and electricity production - but it will inevitably happen. In many parts of the world energy supply is already struggling to keep pace with demand.
But what else is there?
Governments and corporations the world over are turning to "biofuels" to try and compensate for falling oil production. But the math just doesn't add up: the rate of conversion from sunlight to chemical energy is far too slow to allow it to meet the current demand for oil. Besides which, studies seem to show that in many cases you use about as much oil producing the crop (for powering farm machinery etc) as you get back from the crop in the final product, making the whole enterprise a waste of oil and food at this point in time. Technological advances may make the process more efficient in the future, though, so continued research is worthwhile.
Solar photovoltaic technology - which uses tricks of physics to convert sunlight falling on a substance directly into electricity - has a similar problem. The technology keeps getting better but there's a limited amount of the raw materials needed to make the panels and producing them consumes significant amounts of energy. We probably can't produce enough of them and they don't give back enough energy to make them a silver bullet solution to our electricity dependency, but again more research is needed.
Heating water with solar collectors is a no-brainer and I applaud moves from the Queensland government to phase out the old electric-powered type. Wish it would happen sooner.
Using wind to generate electricty (converting kinetic energy from the moving air into electrical energy in the turbine) is also a pretty smart idea. The wind moves because the Sun heats the air, so tapping into that energy flow is sustainable in the true sense of the word. There are some concerns about the amount of energy used in construction vs the amount of energy the turbine can harness over its lifetime, but those issues can probably be solved through engineering.
Hydro-electric systems are also driven by the Sun. It's the Sun which heats the water and causes it to evaporate. It's the Sun which drives the wind that carries the vapour up over the higher land, imbuing it with gravitational potential energy. As the water flows down again towards sea level we can extract some of that energy to turn a turbine and convert it to electricity.
Wave and/or tidal energy. Waves are caused by the wind, which in turn is powered by the Sun, and there's a colossal amount of kinetic energy in the movement of the water. Harnessing that's a great idea. The tides are due to the gravitational pull of the Moon on the water. Taking energy from that system will actually cause the Moon to orbit more slowly and crash into Earth... but that's going to happen eventually anyway and it's unlikely we'll make any significant impact. (No pun intended.)
Geothermal (hot rocks). Not, strictly speaking, a renewable resource but definitely a clean one. Worth looking at where the geology is appropriate.
Nuclear. Ah, had to get to this eventually. Ultimately, nuclear energy is a form of stored energy that was locked into atoms by long-dead stars. It's completely natural but - like molten lava or the Sydney funnelweb spider - not something you want to get too close to. It's interesting to note that some of the geothermal heat which people want to harness was actually released during the radioactive decay of unstable nuclei. There is a lot of nuclear energy available to us here on Earth but like fossil fuels there are undesirable side-effects and it's not a renewable resource.
And that, pretty much, is it. We need to stop using fossil fuels now due to global warming but we will simply run out of oil soon anyway. Nuclear technology will continue to play a role in the global energy mix for a very long time, and it's possible that new developments could greatly reduce the risks associated with radioactive waste and other concerns. The rest of them are all important because none of them can supply so much energy in such a convenient form as fossil fuels have done for the past couple of centuries.
There's a lot of work needed to secure energy supplies and maintain a habitable planet, even just for the rest of this century. I've started doing my bit and you can too.
Thanks so much for reading this far. Questions, comments, corrections all are welcome.
Monday, 4 June 2007
Understanding Energy - Part 1 of 2
As I talk with people and as I read what comes of the mainstream press and government departments, I frequently get the impression that there's a general lack of understanding about energy. There are plenty of other topics about which you could say exactly the same thing of course, but at this point in human history I believe that energy is something we really need to have a good grip on.
So I hope you'll permit me to go all explanatory for a bit. I promise it's really important and not very hard to understand. But it is too much for one post so I'm breaking it up into two. Today we'll look at what energy is and what it does. I'll follow that up with a post on how that's related to our modern world and the usual content of this site. So...
I'll start out with a really simple definition: Energy is what changes things.
Most of the obvious changes relate to how fast something is moving and in which direction: driving a car or hitting a tennis ball are intuitive examples of the way energy can be applied to change an object's motion. The energy that a moving object has is called kinetic energy.
But energy can take many forms (including the form of matter, as Einstein famously described in his "E equals m c squared" formula). Here are a few more:
Even the smallest objects, right down to atoms and molecules, move. As with large objects, the faster they're moving, the more kinetic energy they possess. But atoms have another kind of moving energy too. They can absorb energy in a form which makes them wriggle and bounce about in completely random ways. This atomic-level "Peter Garrett impersonation energy" is what we simply refer to as heat.
There's a very familiar and useful but extremely complex form of energy called electromagnetic radiation. This includes light, radio waves, x-rays, microwaves and so on.
And there are a number of kinds of fields in which energy can be stored and retrieved. One easy example is a gravitational field: you store energy in a gravitational field by raising an object to a higher position. That energy is released from the field as the object is allowed to fall. Other kinds of fields include electric and magnetic fields. Energy stored in fields is known as potential energy.
There are others but that'll do for now. Now that we've established that energy can take different forms, it mightn't surprise you to hear that energy can be converted from one form to another. Take the falling object as an example: at its highest point, before it starts to fall, it has a lot of gravitational potential energy but no kinetic energy (ie, it's not moving). When it's let go and allowed to start falling, the potential energy is converted to kinetic energy. As it falls lower and lower more and more energy comes out of the field and becomes embodied in the increasing downward speed of the object.
It's the conversion of energy from one form to another which enables most of the interesting changes in the universe - including life itself. But there are two rules to the energy game which you have to know before you can play...
1. Energy cannot be created or destroyed.
2. Whenever energy is used, some of it gets "lost" and can't be used again.
(In case you're wondering... yes, that does mean that eventually all the energy in the universe will be "lost" and nothing will ever change again. But don't sweat it - that's not going to happen for an incredibly long time.)
Right. So now you've got a grip on the rules, let me give you a quick update on the state of play in the great game of life on Earth.
For almost five billion years, our little rock has been spinning through the cold empty vacuum of space in orbit around an enormous nuclear fusion reactor. As a result of that reactor converting large quantities of matter into electromagnetic energy which travels quite efficiently through space, the Earth has had a steady stream of energy available to convert into different forms and enable all sorts of change.
In the early days most of the conversion was directly into heat, but a combination of heat and some tricky light-powered chemical reactions gradually snowballed to produce a soup of carbon-based compounds. At some point, and through a mechanism not clearly understood, life began.
Life and energy are inseparable. Life, by definition, must grow and sustain and replicate itself. Growth is change and energy is what changes things. And for all practical purposes, all of the energy for all of the things which have ever lived on this planet has come from the Sun.
The essential flow of energy goes like this:
Next time we'll look at why our modern abundance of energy is basically a once-off freak accident and why there is so much concern about what is going to happen to our civilisation as the Earth's energy flow returns to its four-billion-year-old business as usual.
So I hope you'll permit me to go all explanatory for a bit. I promise it's really important and not very hard to understand. But it is too much for one post so I'm breaking it up into two. Today we'll look at what energy is and what it does. I'll follow that up with a post on how that's related to our modern world and the usual content of this site. So...
I'll start out with a really simple definition: Energy is what changes things.
Most of the obvious changes relate to how fast something is moving and in which direction: driving a car or hitting a tennis ball are intuitive examples of the way energy can be applied to change an object's motion. The energy that a moving object has is called kinetic energy.
But energy can take many forms (including the form of matter, as Einstein famously described in his "E equals m c squared" formula). Here are a few more:
Even the smallest objects, right down to atoms and molecules, move. As with large objects, the faster they're moving, the more kinetic energy they possess. But atoms have another kind of moving energy too. They can absorb energy in a form which makes them wriggle and bounce about in completely random ways. This atomic-level "Peter Garrett impersonation energy" is what we simply refer to as heat.
There's a very familiar and useful but extremely complex form of energy called electromagnetic radiation. This includes light, radio waves, x-rays, microwaves and so on.
And there are a number of kinds of fields in which energy can be stored and retrieved. One easy example is a gravitational field: you store energy in a gravitational field by raising an object to a higher position. That energy is released from the field as the object is allowed to fall. Other kinds of fields include electric and magnetic fields. Energy stored in fields is known as potential energy.
There are others but that'll do for now. Now that we've established that energy can take different forms, it mightn't surprise you to hear that energy can be converted from one form to another. Take the falling object as an example: at its highest point, before it starts to fall, it has a lot of gravitational potential energy but no kinetic energy (ie, it's not moving). When it's let go and allowed to start falling, the potential energy is converted to kinetic energy. As it falls lower and lower more and more energy comes out of the field and becomes embodied in the increasing downward speed of the object.
It's the conversion of energy from one form to another which enables most of the interesting changes in the universe - including life itself. But there are two rules to the energy game which you have to know before you can play...
1. Energy cannot be created or destroyed.
2. Whenever energy is used, some of it gets "lost" and can't be used again.
(In case you're wondering... yes, that does mean that eventually all the energy in the universe will be "lost" and nothing will ever change again. But don't sweat it - that's not going to happen for an incredibly long time.)
Right. So now you've got a grip on the rules, let me give you a quick update on the state of play in the great game of life on Earth.
For almost five billion years, our little rock has been spinning through the cold empty vacuum of space in orbit around an enormous nuclear fusion reactor. As a result of that reactor converting large quantities of matter into electromagnetic energy which travels quite efficiently through space, the Earth has had a steady stream of energy available to convert into different forms and enable all sorts of change.
In the early days most of the conversion was directly into heat, but a combination of heat and some tricky light-powered chemical reactions gradually snowballed to produce a soup of carbon-based compounds. At some point, and through a mechanism not clearly understood, life began.
Life and energy are inseparable. Life, by definition, must grow and sustain and replicate itself. Growth is change and energy is what changes things. And for all practical purposes, all of the energy for all of the things which have ever lived on this planet has come from the Sun.
The essential flow of energy goes like this:
- Plants convert energy from sunlight into stored chemical energy, with some "lost" as heat in the conversion process.
- Things which eat plants use some of that stored chemical energy to create their own tissues (muscle, blood etc), with some energy retained in the new chemical bonds and some "lost" as heat.
- Plant eaters also convert some of the plants' stored energy into energy of motion (walking, chewing etc) which is ultimately all "lost" as heat.
- Meat eaters rely on the chemical energy they obtain from the tissues of the plant eaters to power their own growth and movement - and of course most of that is "lost" as heat during the lifetime of the animal.
- Eventually all things die, but the energy in their tissues is fought over by lifeforms ranging from the smallest bacteria to the largest carnivorous scavenger. Some of the energy may get recycled (dead thing -> fungus -> plant eater -> meat eater) but at each step of the way some of the Sun's original input gets "lost" as heat, never to power the changes of life again.
Next time we'll look at why our modern abundance of energy is basically a once-off freak accident and why there is so much concern about what is going to happen to our civilisation as the Earth's energy flow returns to its four-billion-year-old business as usual.
Saturday, 5 May 2007
In hot water
Some aspects of attempting to live more sustainably are easy, even fun. But I'm finding that there are some real sacrifices required too.
One of my favourite things in the whole world is a long hot shower. It washes away the grime and stress of the day. It relaxes the muscles and the mind. It's an oasis of calm where exuberant or grouchy two-year-olds can be legitimately shut out of your attention for a short(ish) moment in time. With all the distractions out of the way and the body being calmed it's a perfect place for dreaming up solutions to problems big and small, or mentally rehearsing for some task or exam which you might be facing.
But for all its personal benefits it's also a slap in the face of sustainable living.
For starters there's the water. In some parts of the world this is less of a problem (the best shower I've ever had was a fancy double-headed setup in a hotel in San Francisco where I'm told the water is plentiful) but in Brisbane, Australia we're so short of water that we're banned from washing our cars and are being urged to limit our showers to four minutes a day.
Four minutes is certainly sufficient to carry out the tasks essential for hygiene, though I've had to stop using my "ShowerShave" anti-fog mirror and have reverted to shaving over the bathroom sink. But it just doesn't make the grade in terms of relaxation or problem solving. Sometimes I compromise by turning the water right down so it's literally a very hot trickle and extending my stay for another minute or three. Wish I was rich and extravagant enough to get one of these installed.
But this isn't a brag post... it's a confession. Because even though I'm making sacrifices to save water, my home is among the inefficient greenhouse-gas-spewing majority when it comes to heating the water in the first place.
We bought this place a couple of years ago and along with it the existing "electric storage" hot water system. That's the common variety which has a big tank at ground level and an electric heating element inside it. Using electricity to produce heat is horrendously wasteful and inefficient - more on this in a later post - but compared to the technology these systems replaced (which involved chopping wood) they are vastly more convenient and relatively cheap to run. That is, they're cheap when you source the energy from burning coal.
I'm investigating my options for installing a water heater that will make use of some of the plentiful solar energy that's available in this region. One involves a $4,000 outlay over two years for a system that keeps the tank at ground level and uses a small electric pump to cycle water up through the solar collectors on the roof. There's also the more common type which puts the storage tank on the roof above the collectors, allowing gravity to pull the colder water down, but I have no way of knowing whether our roof is designed to take all that weight. Will check it out.
Whichever way I look at this, sustainable living is going to cost me when it comes to my beloved hot shower.
One of my favourite things in the whole world is a long hot shower. It washes away the grime and stress of the day. It relaxes the muscles and the mind. It's an oasis of calm where exuberant or grouchy two-year-olds can be legitimately shut out of your attention for a short(ish) moment in time. With all the distractions out of the way and the body being calmed it's a perfect place for dreaming up solutions to problems big and small, or mentally rehearsing for some task or exam which you might be facing.
But for all its personal benefits it's also a slap in the face of sustainable living.
For starters there's the water. In some parts of the world this is less of a problem (the best shower I've ever had was a fancy double-headed setup in a hotel in San Francisco where I'm told the water is plentiful) but in Brisbane, Australia we're so short of water that we're banned from washing our cars and are being urged to limit our showers to four minutes a day.
Four minutes is certainly sufficient to carry out the tasks essential for hygiene, though I've had to stop using my "ShowerShave" anti-fog mirror and have reverted to shaving over the bathroom sink. But it just doesn't make the grade in terms of relaxation or problem solving. Sometimes I compromise by turning the water right down so it's literally a very hot trickle and extending my stay for another minute or three. Wish I was rich and extravagant enough to get one of these installed.
But this isn't a brag post... it's a confession. Because even though I'm making sacrifices to save water, my home is among the inefficient greenhouse-gas-spewing majority when it comes to heating the water in the first place.
We bought this place a couple of years ago and along with it the existing "electric storage" hot water system. That's the common variety which has a big tank at ground level and an electric heating element inside it. Using electricity to produce heat is horrendously wasteful and inefficient - more on this in a later post - but compared to the technology these systems replaced (which involved chopping wood) they are vastly more convenient and relatively cheap to run. That is, they're cheap when you source the energy from burning coal.
I'm investigating my options for installing a water heater that will make use of some of the plentiful solar energy that's available in this region. One involves a $4,000 outlay over two years for a system that keeps the tank at ground level and uses a small electric pump to cycle water up through the solar collectors on the roof. There's also the more common type which puts the storage tank on the roof above the collectors, allowing gravity to pull the colder water down, but I have no way of knowing whether our roof is designed to take all that weight. Will check it out.
Whichever way I look at this, sustainable living is going to cost me when it comes to my beloved hot shower.
Labels:
confessions,
efficiency,
energy,
solar,
water
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)